The Dirtpile
Cover art for File 5: USAID

File 05 · 5:53 Out now on Spotify

USAID

USAID, the U.S. Agency for International Development, and about $4 billion in foreign aid that expired before any court decided whether it should have been spent. In August 2025, the President asked Congress to cancel money it had already approved, then held it until it ran out, a move known as a pocket rescission. File five follows the aid freeze, the lawsuits, the Supreme Court's early-stage order, a watchdog that called it "not permitted by law," and a case still open as of November 2026.

Listen on Spotify

Chapters

  1. 0:00 Cold open: five billion dollars, thirty-three days
  2. 0:41 The freeze
  3. 1:36 Who can sue
  4. 2:09 The pocket rescission
  5. 2:57 The Supreme Court steps in
  6. 3:35 After the money expired
  7. 3:57 The case goes on
  8. 4:41 The second rescission
  9. 5:05 Side by side
  10. 5:27 Our question

Transcript

The episode as narrated, with years shown as numerals. Archival tape is quoted from the official record.

0:00 Cold open: five billion dollars, thirty-three days

On August 28, 2025, an appeals court ruling on foreign aid took effect. That day, the President asked Congress to cancel nearly five billion dollars it had already approved, mostly foreign aid. All of it would expire in thirty-three days, including about four billion dollars in foreign aid. By law, a President may hold such money while Congress decides, for up to forty-five days, not counting long breaks.

Whether that hold can outlast the money is in dispute. Welcome to The Dirtpile. One scandal at a time. File five: USAID.

0:41 The freeze

In 2024, Congress had provided more than thirty billion dollars for foreign aid through the State Department and USAID, the U.S. Agency for International Development. On his first day back, the President paused development aid for ninety days, saying the foreign aid bureaucracy was "not aligned with American interests." The State Department halted existing grants and contracts, with exceptions for lifesaving aid. USAID's internal watchdog, its inspector general, warned that with the pause, and most of its humanitarian staff sidelined or about to be, its oversight controls were "largely nonoperational."

Aid groups sued, and a federal judge blocked the blanket freeze. The Secretary of State said USAID had strayed from its mission, and that "the gains were too few and the costs were too high." So what happened to the money, and who had the power to decide?

1:36 Who can sue

In July, Congress narrowly approved most of an earlier request, canceling billions in foreign aid. In August, an appeals panel ruled that the aid groups couldn't sue under the Impoundment Control Act. That's the 1970-four law that limits a President's power to hold back money Congress has approved. Under it, the panel said, Congress's own watchdog could sue.

The panel left other claims open. The new request's largest item said many programs "conflicted with American values" while "providing no clear benefit to Americans."

2:09 The pocket rescission

The government argued the forty-five-day hold is allowed even if the money expires first. A rescission is Congress canceling money it already approved. When a hold outlasts the money, it's sometimes called a pocket rescission: the money expires without Congress voting to cancel it. The government also noted that Congress wrote a year-end limit into the law for spending delays, but not for cancellation requests.

Its lawyer told the judge that money was "not available" to commit to grants and contracts, because it was in the request. The judge ordered it committed by September 30, unless Congress canceled it. The watchdog, the Government Accountability Office, which audits federal spending for Congress, called withholding funds past expiration "not permitted by law." It has not sued, as far as public records show.

2:57 The Supreme Court steps in

On September 26, the Supreme Court paused the order for that money. At this early stage, it said, the government had made "a sufficient showing" that the impoundment law bars the suit. It said the asserted harm to the executive branch's "conduct of foreign affairs" appeared to outweigh the potential harm to the groups. But it said its order "should not be read as a final determination on the merits," meaning it had not decided who was right.

Three justices who disagreed wrote that the money "will now never reach its intended recipients." The fiscal year ended four days later; the government says the funds "have lapsed," meaning they expired.

3:35 After the money expired

A July 2025 modeling study in The Lancet projected millions of added deaths by 2030 if that year's early aid cuts persisted. It covers all USAID funding and can't be tied to this four billion. In February, Congress funded global health programs at about nine point four billion dollars for fiscal 2026.

3:57 The case goes on

The suit also claims USAID was unlawfully abolished; the administration calls it a reorganization. This September, the judge let most claims go forward, calling the money dispute "capable of repetition": the kind that can happen again, and end before courts can rule. That ruling only let the case go on; the full record, the judge wrote, "may well show" the government acted lawfully. Five days later, as more aid money in the case was due to expire, he ordered it kept available while the case goes on, a step the government had told him he could take.

The government says that by the deadline it committed nearly all of the money it considers available; the aid groups challenge billions it put toward winding down programs.

4:41 The second rescission

On the day of that September ruling, the President sent another pocket rescission, mostly for domestic programs. The watchdog said any such withholding, "regardless of size, subverts" Congress's "power of the purse." Congress hasn't voted on it; seven states and ten nonprofits have sued. A deadline can arrive before a court decides whether money should have been spent.

5:05 Side by side

The record leaves these side by side. Congress's votes to cut, and money it never voted to cancel. A "sufficient showing," and not "a final determination." A watchdog's "not permitted by law," and no lawsuit of its own.

No final ruling, and the same move made again.

5:27 Our question

Here's our own question, not an official finding. Was that four billion dollars lawfully withheld, and will a court ever finally decide? This is The Dirtpile. One scandal at a time.

Sources

Credits

  • Narrated with a synthesized voice (ElevenLabs). No archival tape.