The Dirtpile
Cover art for File 6: DOGE

File 06 · 7:08 Out now on Spotify

DOGE

DOGE, the Department of Government Efficiency, and its access to Social Security data on nearly everyone with a Social Security number. File six asks whether the “150-year-olds” were real, how DOGE’s $215 billion savings claim fared with Congress’s auditor, and what happened when unions and retirees sued under the Privacy Act: a judge’s block, a Supreme Court order letting access resume, and the government’s own corrections ten months later. No court has made a final ruling on whether the access was legal; the case remains open as of November 2026.

Listen on Spotify

Chapters

  1. 0:00 Cold open
  2. 0:31 The order creating DOGE
  3. 0:53 How the team got in
  4. 1:11 The 150-year-olds claim
  5. 2:09 Payments after death
  6. 2:30 The savings claim
  7. 3:12 The lawsuit
  8. 3:47 The Supreme Court steps in
  9. 4:03 The appeals argument
  10. 4:49 The government's corrections
  11. 5:34 The full appeals court
  12. 5:52 Back in the trial court
  13. 6:20 Side by side
  14. 6:38 Our question

Transcript

The episode as narrated, with years shown as numerals. Archival tape is quoted from the official record.

0:00 Cold open

In February 2025, a new team arrived at the Social Security Administration. A former senior official later swore that a DOGE representative kept saying one engineer needed access to "everything, including source code." Within weeks, the team could see personal data on nearly everyone with a Social Security number. Welcome to The Dirtpile.

One scandal at a time. File six: DOGE.

0:31 The order creating DOGE

On his first day back, the President signed an order creating DOGE, the Department of Government Efficiency. It told agency heads, "to the maximum extent consistent with law," to give DOGE "full and prompt access to all unclassified agency records." So what did DOGE get at Social Security, and what has the government admitted?

0:53 How the team got in

At Social Security, as the appeals court later put it, "career officials resigned," and a new acting head "granted DOGE the sweeping access it sought." The government concedes the team got access to personal data in benefit and payment records, and the master file of Social Security numbers.

1:11 The 150-year-olds claim

On February 11, the day before that access began, Elon Musk, then a senior adviser to the President, joined him in the Oval Office.

Archival tape: Oval Office, Feb. 11, 2025 (official White House recording)

Elon Musk: “So, you know, there's crazy things like just [a] cursory examination of Social Security, and we've got people in there that are 150 years old.”

Moments later, Musk said, "I think they're probably dead." No one alive was anywhere near a hundred fifty. In 2023, the agency's inspector general, its internal watchdog, had found eighteen point nine million records of people born in 1920 or earlier with no death on file. It said most had likely died decades ago, before deaths were reported electronically.

Agency officials said almost none were being paid; the inspector general counted about forty-four thousand, and didn't say whether they were alive. Three weeks after Musk's remark, the President told Congress, "money is being paid to many of them."

2:09 Payments after death

Payments after death do happen. One audit estimated three hundred twenty-seven million dollars was paid to about sixteen thousand people after they died, because the agency had rejected valid state death reports. But from 2015 through 2022, payment errors of every kind, mostly overpayments, came to under one percent of benefits.

2:30 The savings claim

DOGE's website still claims two hundred fifteen billion dollars in savings. The Government Accountability Office, Congress's nonpartisan auditor, checked the half tied to contracts, grants and leases. It found some estimates "incorrect or lack supporting evidence," and couldn't say whether those savings were too high or too low. On twenty-one sampled contracts, DOGE claimed seven and a half billion dollars; the auditors found about seventy-eight million taken back, plus billions in lowered contract limits that may or may not become savings.

DOGE's website counts the other half too, from job cuts to fraud; no auditor has checked that half. None of these numbers answers who should see the data.

3:12 The lawsuit

Two unions and a retirees' group sued. They cited the Privacy Act, a 1970-four law limiting how agencies share people's records; one exception covers staff who need them for their jobs. The groups said personal data must stay within "the circle of those who truly need it." The government argued staff charged with rooting out fraud "plainly need access to those systems."

In March, a federal judge temporarily blocked the team's access to personal data. She said the team was on a "fishing expedition," with no "reasonable explanation" given for such wide access.

3:47 The Supreme Court steps in

In June, the Supreme Court paused her order during the appeal, letting access resume, without explaining its reasoning. That August, an agency whistleblower alleged a copy of the master file was put in a DOGE-run cloud without the usual security approval.

4:03 The appeals argument

In September 2025, before the government's corrections, the full appeals court heard arguments. Here's the lawyer for the unions and retirees.

Archival tape: Fourth Circuit argument, Sept. 11, 2025 (court recording)

Lawyer for the unions and retirees: “The government cannot grant itself an all-access pass to confidential, sensitive information merely by baldly asserting the word need or even the word fraud.”

Then the government's lawyer.

Archival tape: Same argument

Government's lawyer: “There was no allegation in the whistleblower complaint that any third party has in fact gained access to any records [that] they're not entitled to.”

Five days after the argument, the agency's commissioner told a senator its acting security chief had found the whistleblower's claim "unfounded." No court has ruled on that claim.

4:49 The government's corrections

In January 2026, the government corrected its sworn account from March 2025. It called some team actions "potentially" outside policy or the judge's order. Team members had shared data on an unapproved outside server; the agency couldn't determine "exactly what data were shared." The agency swore access was cut off as of March 24; that morning, one member was still searching the master file's personal data.

A political advocacy group asked two members to analyze state voter rolls; one signed a data agreement with it, without agency approval. The agency had "not yet seen evidence" that its data reached the group. The filing admitted these facts, not a violation of the Privacy Act.

5:34 The full appeals court

In April 2026, the full appeals court lifted the block, nine to six. The majority found no showing of harm that couldn't be repaired later. The six who disagreed called much of the government's earlier information "patently false." No court has made a final ruling on whether the access was legal.

5:52 Back in the trial court

The government says the agency "no longer has a DOGE Team," though its sworn statement notes two current executives with past DOGE ties. It asks the judge to end the case as moot, meaning nothing is left to fix. She let the groups demand documents and sworn answers, called discovery, on whether the government obeyed her order and was candid with the court. She hasn't ruled on ending the case; as of November 2026, it remains open.

6:20 Side by side

The record leaves these side by side. A sworn account, and its corrections ten months later. "Fishing expedition," and "plainly need access." "No longer has a DOGE Team," and two executives with past ties to it.

6:38 Our question

Here's our own question, not an official finding. What did DOGE's team do with the data it could see, and will this case ever show us? This is The Dirtpile. One scandal at a time.

Sources

Credits

  • Narration: synthesized with ElevenLabs (voice: Dean).
  • Archival audio:
  • Elon Musk, Oval Office, Feb. 11, 2025. Official White House video, a U.S. government work (17 U.S.C. § 105). Press-pool caveat noted.
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, oral argument in AFSCME v. SSA, Sept. 11, 2025: counsel for the plaintiffs, and counsel for the government. The court's own recording, a U.S. government work (17 U.S.C. § 105).