The Dirtpile
Cover art for File 4: The Epstein Files

File 04 · 5:58 Out now on Spotify

The Epstein Files

The Epstein files: what the Justice Department released, what it held back, and why. In July 2025, the department said no further disclosure was warranted. That November, the House passed the Epstein Files Transparency Act 427 to 1, and the President signed it. File four follows what came next: about 3.5 million pages released, privileges the law never listed, thousands of documents removed because they may have identified victims, and a federal lawsuit and an inspector general audit still open as of November 2026.

Listen on Spotify

Chapters

  1. 0:00 Cold open: the memo and the Cabinet meeting
  2. 0:54 From "no further disclosure" to a new law
  3. 1:28 What the law allowed
  4. 2:08 The deadline and the page counts
  5. 2:59 Privileges and foreign-language files
  6. 3:39 Victims' names
  7. 4:16 In court
  8. 5:10 Side by side
  9. 5:33 Our question

Transcript

The episode as narrated, with years shown as numerals. Archival tape is quoted from the official record.

0:00 Cold open: the memo and the Cabinet meeting

In July 2025, the Justice Department and the FBI made public a memo on their review of the Jeffrey Epstein files. It said "no further disclosure would be appropriate or warranted." The next day, at a Cabinet meeting, a reporter asked the Attorney General about the memo and the jail video released with it, and the President cut in.

Archival tape: Remarks following a Cabinet meeting, July 8, 2025 (official White House recording)

Donald Trump: “Are you still talking about Jeffrey Epstein? This guy has been talked about for years. You're asking—we have Texas, we have this, we have all of the things. … And are people still talking about this guy— [Reporter: They are.] —this creep? [Reporter: There's a lot of interest, yes.] That is unbelievable.”

That November, he signed a law ordering the files released. Welcome to The Dirtpile. One scandal at a time. File four: The Epstein Files.

0:54 From "no further disclosure" to a new law

The memo said the review found no incriminating "client list," and no evidence that could justify investigating uncharged third parties. It said victims' information was "intertwined throughout," and that much of the material was under court seal. In Congress, members of both parties went around House leadership with a discharge petition to force a vote. President Trump, who had called the matter a hoax, then urged House Republicans to vote for release, "because we have nothing to hide."

The House passed the Epstein Files Transparency Act, four hundred twenty-seven to one.

1:28 What the law allowed

The Senate passed it without changes, and the President signed it. So what did the department hold back, and how did it handle victims' identities? The law gave thirty days, and five reasons to withhold or redact. Victims' personal information, child sexual abuse material, active investigations, images of death, abuse, or injury, and classified material.

Nothing could be held back for "embarrassment, reputational harm, or political sensitivity." Before the vote, the Speaker of the House had put a warning in the Congressional Record that the bill failed to fully protect victims' privacy.

2:08 The deadline and the page counts

The deadline came on December 19. That day, the department released hundreds of thousands of pages, and said the rest would follow on a rolling basis. On January 30, six weeks after the deadline, it declared compliance at about three and a half million pages. The department had collected more than six million potentially responsive pages.

It says the rest were duplicates, unrelated material, or pages withheld under the Act or legal privileges. The Republican congressman who filed the discharge petition said in July that more than three million files were still being unlawfully withheld. One count is pages, the other is files, and neither, on its own, shows what is missing. The department withheld or redacted about two hundred thousand pages under legal privileges the Act does not list.

It says Congress never clearly overrode them.

2:59 Privileges and foreign-language files

As of this month, we found no court ruling on that question. It held back foreign-language documents, saying it wasn't practicable for first-level reviewers to judge whether they were responsive. It also redacted email addresses under the Privacy Act, and some government personnel names. What the department calls the written justification the Act requires came eight months after the deadline: a republished February report.

That report says officials named in the files appear "in a wide variety of contexts." A name in these files is not evidence of wrongdoing. Victims' lawyers had supplied more than twelve hundred names of victims and relatives to redact.

3:39 Victims' names

Days after the January release, the department told a federal court it had removed "several thousands of documents and media" that may have identified victims. Victims' lawyers called the harm "irreversible." The department had already acknowledged that "inconsistencies will likely exist in how reviewers applied redactions." In June, a federal judge rejected the department's argument that a private citizen had no right to sue over the Act, and issued a preliminary injunction.

In September, he called the foreign-language reasoning "without merit," and ordered handwritten FBI notes turned over for his private review.

4:16 In court

On November 9, he ordered three sets of those notes published with redactions, giving the department two weeks to seek a stay on appeal. But after reviewing the ten redactions the lawsuit challenged, he found that all of them covered victims' names, private email addresses, or government personnel. He left open whether the law allows Privacy Act redactions, and whether that February report suffices. The department has appealed, and in October the appeals court refused to pause his earlier orders while it decides.

The department now says it has begun reviewing the foreign-language files. Its inspector general is still auditing its compliance. The department says no records were withheld for "political sensitivity," and that "notable individuals and politicians were not redacted." A transparency law is tested twice: by what comes out, and by who stays protected.

5:10 Side by side

The record leaves these side by side. "No further disclosure," and three and a half million pages. Five reasons in the law, and privileges it never named. Over twelve hundred names to redact, and thousands of documents removed.

Compliance declared, and a court case and an audit still open.

5:33 Our question

Here's our own question, not an official finding. Beyond the five reasons Congress allowed, what was held back, on whose authority, and at what cost to the survivors? This is The Dirtpile. One scandal at a time.

Sources

Credits

  • Narrated with a synthesized voice (ElevenLabs). Archival audio: official White House video of the July 8, 2025 Cabinet meeting (U.S. government work, public domain).